Current:Home > ContactNovaQuant-Pennsylvania high court takes up challenge to the state’s life-without-parole sentences -CapitalTrack
NovaQuant-Pennsylvania high court takes up challenge to the state’s life-without-parole sentences
Surpassing Quant Think Tank Center View
Date:2025-04-10 09:47:46
HARRISBURG,NovaQuant Pa. (AP) — Pennsylvania’s high court will consider whether some automatic life sentences for those convicted of murder violate constitutional protections for defendants, the justices said Friday.
The appeal being pursued by Derek Lee, convicted of a 2014 killing, argues the state’s life-without-parole law violates prohibitions in the Pennsylvania and U.S. constitutions against cruel punishment.
In the order accepting the appeal, the Supreme Court said it would focus on the constitutionality of the mandatory life sentence in Lee’s case, where he argues he “did not kill or intend to kill and therefore had categorically-diminished culpability.”
Pennsylvania law makes someone liable for murder if they participate in a felony that leads to death, and life with no possibility of parole is currently the state’s only possible sentence for those convicted of second-degree murder.
Advocates say there are about 5,200 people in Pennsylvania currently serving what they call “death by incarceration” sentences, the highest per capita rate among states. The policy affects Black men disproportionately, as about 70% of those serving life-without-parole in Pennsylvania are Black.
Quinn Cozzens, a lawyer for Lee with the Abolitionist Law Center, said he believes if the high court sides with Lee, that could apply to all others convicted of second-degree murder.
“The only issue that we’re appealing from trial is the sentence itself, so not the conviction,” Cozzens said. “So even on the theory that the state’s proved its case entirely and everything’s entirely true, that sentence is still excessive and doesn’t reflect the culpability of somebody convicted of felony murder.”
Kelly Callihan, executive director of the Pennsylvania District Attorneys Association, said the case will be reviewed by the association’s appeals committee to determine next steps.
A summary of the facts of the October 2014 killing written by the Allegheny County trial judge said Lee and another man, both armed and with their faces partially concealed, forced the home’s two adult residents to kneel while they yelled at victim Leonard Butler to give them money. One assailant used a stun gun.
One of them pistol-whipped the 44-year-old Butler in the face, took his watch and ran up the stairs, the judge said.
“The second male remained with the couple and when Butler began to struggle with him over the gun, a shot was fired killing Butler,” the judge wrote.
Investigators linked Lee to the crime because a rental vehicle in his name had been parked outside around the time of the killing, and because the other adult resident of the home identified him out of a photo lineup, saying Lee was not the shooter, the judge recounted.
Lee and codefendant Paul Durham were both convicted by a jury of second-degree murder, robbery and conspiracy.
In a June ruling, the Pennsylvania Superior Court cited decisions in previous, similar appeals as it turned down Lee’s claim that life-without-parole violates his constitutional rights.
But in a concurring opinion, Superior Court Judge Alice Beck Dubow urged the higher court to revisit the matter “in light of changes in related case law from other states and research and policy concerns regarding the criminal justice system.”
.
veryGood! (7255)
Related
- Residents worried after ceiling cracks appear following reroofing works at Jalan Tenaga HDB blocks
- Air Pollution Could Potentially Exacerbate Menopause Symptoms, Study Says
- Montana man gets 2 1/2 years in prison for leaving threatening voicemails for Senator Jon Tester
- Ford recalls over 240,000 Maverick pickups due to tail lights that fail to illuminate
- Friday the 13th luck? 13 past Mega Millions jackpot wins in December. See top 10 lottery prizes
- No criminal charges after 4 newborn bodies found in a freezer
- The newest Crocs have a sudsy, woodsy appeal. Here's how to win or buy new Busch Light Crocs
- Kansas tornado leaves 1 dead, destroys nearly two dozen homes, officials say
- 'No Good Deed': Who's the killer in the Netflix comedy? And will there be a Season 2?
- 1 dead,14 injured after driver crashes into New Mexico store
Ranking
- Friday the 13th luck? 13 past Mega Millions jackpot wins in December. See top 10 lottery prizes
- Coming soon to Dave & Buster's: Betting. New app function allows customers to wager on games.
- Trump’s comparison of student protests to Jan. 6 is part of effort to downplay Capitol attack
- World's Strongest Man competition returns: Who to know, how to follow along
- Louvre will undergo expansion and restoration project, Macron says
- United Methodists repeal longstanding ban on LGBTQ clergy
- Slipknot announces Here Comes the Pain concert tour, return of Knotfest: How to get tickets
- Bounce house swept up by wind kills one child and injures another
Recommendation
Former Syrian official arrested in California who oversaw prison charged with torture
Ryan Gosling and Mikey Day return as Beavis and Butt-Head at 'The Fall Guy' premiere
African nation threatens Apple with legal action over alleged blood minerals in its gadgets
How rare Devils Hole pupfish populations came back to life in Death Valley
Finally, good retirement news! Southwest pilots' plan is a bright spot, experts say
'Dad' of Wally, the missing emotional support alligator, makes tearful plea for his return
E. coli outbreak: Walnuts sold in at least 19 states linked to illnesses in California and Washington
Ford recalls Maverick pickups in US because tail lights can go dark, increasing the risk of a crash